Михаил Назаренко (petro_gulak) wrote,
Михаил Назаренко
petro_gulak

Поддержка и опора

Недавно мне указали на совершенный мною невольный плагиат (по счастью, не в научной работе!). Через день мне попалось на глаза утешительное мнение Орсона Скотта Карда по данному вопросу:

Many writers, however, far from borrowing or seeking to be "influenced," are desperately afraid of inadvertent influence to the point of paranoia. Since every good idea has already been used, getting too anxious about such chance resemblances is a waste of time.
Here's my rule: Any idea you really like that absolutely works for your story is your idea, no matter who else might have used it before. The only limitation on this is what the audience will stand for - if you end your novel with the hero standing before a fire and the only way the ring gets thrown in is because someone else bites off his finger and then falls in, well, your audience is likely to be a bit disgusted - the resemblance is too close, the source way too well-known. Only if your intent is humorous can you get away with it.
You should not be penalized for having read widely, however. If your story has elements that you recognize as being similar to a book by someone else, so what? As long as it's your own story, and those motifs feel important and true within the context of your work, they're your ideas now.

(O.S.Card. Uncle Orson's Writing Class. Lesson 7 - On Plagiarism, Borrowing, Resemblance, and Influence.)
Subscribe

  • После ясно-кристальных дней

    Я зажег на горах красный факел войны. Разгораяся лижут лазурность огни. Неужели опять для меня суждены Эти звонкие, ясно-кристальные дни? (Гумилев,…

  • Current mood

    Сова-Диоген. Чувствую себя совой-Диогеном.

  • Про пошлість і меншовартість

    Вчергове довелося наштовхнутися на твердження: «Кожен, хто повторює твердження про "велику російську культуру", бере участь у війні на боці ворога».…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments